
A designer commission on cabinetry is the compensation question that splits a room of working professionals faster than almost any other. Some firms treat it as the obvious payment for carrying a six-figure scope through pricing, shop drawings, and installation. Others refuse it on principle and bill the same hours as a fee. The difference is rarely about the number.
What a designer commission on cabinetry actually pays for
Strip the question down and it stops being about cabinets. It is about who the client calls when a drawer front arrives in the wrong finish, and who spends the next three weeks making it right.
Designers in the Interior Design Community network split on the answer, but not randomly. The dividing line is responsibility. Where the designer owns the outcome, the money tends to follow. Where the cabinet shop owns it, the money mostly stays there.
One firm put that logic in a single breath, treating accountability and compensation as one decision rather than two.
“Yes!!!!!!!! Any product that you can be held responsible for needs to have a commission. So when we design cabinetry we absolutely take a commission. If you can throw up your hands and say to the client I have nothing to do with an issue that arises, then by all means, don’t take a commission but if you are part of the team that is going to be resolving a problem, you need a kitty to be able to say “we’ve got this!””
@mimiandhill
The operative word is kitty. A commission on a category you are answerable for is not a bonus stacked on your fee, it is the funded reserve that lets you absorb a problem without reopening the client’s budget. Rework hours, expedited freight, a replacement door, a second trip from the installer: someone pays for those.
If your agreement is silent on who, the answer defaults to you. Price the reserve deliberately or carry the risk for free. That puts this much closer to the case for charging a design fee and a markup on the same project than to anything resembling a referral kickback.
Markup, commission, and design fee describe three different transactions
The three words get used interchangeably in conversation, which is why the debate goes in circles. They are not synonyms. They describe who holds the purchase and who holds the exposure.
A markup means the transaction runs through your business. You buy the millwork, you resell it, you own the warranty conversation and the receivable. A commission means the client contracts directly with the shop and the shop pays you a percentage. A design fee means you charge for your labor and never touch the product money.
The practical test is whose name is on the purchase order. One designer described a workflow that keeps the transaction inside the firm from the first drawing to the last reveal.
“I have a pretty simple process. I design all Millwork, send it to my cabinet maker for pricing, then add my markup. I do the same for all the stonework as well. I am hands on throughout the entire process, which works well for not only the client but my suppliers.”
@belgatolampshades
Notice what that model buys. Soliciting the shop’s price yourself, then applying your own markup, means you are never negotiating your compensation with a vendor who views it as a cost of sale. The percentage is yours to set, just as it is on stone or fabric.
It also means the client’s recourse runs through you. Choose that structure only if your operation can carry receiving, punch, and warranty claims on a category where a single error can stall a kitchen for ten weeks.
Why experienced designers decline on this category
The no-camp is not leaving money on the table out of modesty. Their reasoning is structural, and it starts with whose interests sit where.
A cabinet company exists to sell cabinets. A designer specifying that scope is supposed to be the counterweight, the person asking whether the client needs the appliance garage or whether that budget belongs in better drawer hardware. Taking a percentage of the sale complicates that posture, even when the advice stays honest.
“A cabinet companies interest is to sell cabinets. Having a qualified kitchen designer looks out for the clients needs and helps make the (often) most costly room in the house well worth it. I don’t do a commission on cabinets, and for me ideally the person building cabinets is also installing so they have full ownership of the fit and finish, no finger pointing. We are really lucky in my area to have great custom cabinet shops with competitive pricing.”
@prattresidential
The second half of that comment is the part worth stealing. When one trade designs, builds, and installs, there is nobody to point at. Fit and finish belong to a single party, and the client’s remedy is obvious.
Fragment that chain and you inherit the arbitration role whether or not you were paid for it. That is a defensible reason to stay out of the product money on millwork while still charging properly for the drawing set and the coordination hours behind it.
Charging a design fee when the cabinets are not yours to sell
Declining a commission is not the same as working for nothing, and this is where firms most often undercharge. The labor does not shrink because the transaction moved elsewhere.
Designing cabinetry is dimensioned work. Door profiles, interior fittings, filler and scribe conditions, appliance clearances, finish samples approved against a stain draw, and a shop drawing review that catches the mistake before it gets built. None of that disappears when the client’s check goes to the cabinetmaker.
“I don’t take a commission, but I do charge a design fee for designing the cabinetry and working with the cabinetmakers.”
@fernwood_interiors
That is the cleanest version of the model: no percentage, no ambiguity, a fee that names the work. It is the same reasoning behind pricing specification work when someone else handles the buying, and it holds up in a client conversation because the deliverable is visible.
Build the fee from hours you can actually defend. Count the drawing time, the shop meetings, the sample approvals, the site verification, and the two or three rounds of revisions that every custom kitchen generates.
Then draw the boundary in writing. Scope limited to selections only should be priced and documented as selections only, with the cabinetry layout, the dimensioned drawings, and the construction-phase coordination named as separate services a client can add.
Firms that skip that step end up doing the full millwork package at a selections price, which is the quietest way to lose money on a kitchen. The fee model protects you only when the deliverable list is specific enough to argue from.
Disclosure is what separates a fee from a liability
Whichever model you choose, the risk is not the percentage. It is an undisclosed percentage. A client who learns after the fact that a specifier was paid by the vendor they were advised to hire will not be weighing the ethics of commission structures. They will be questioning every recommendation you made.
One designer drew the line precisely, and in terms worth copying into your own paperwork.
“No. Unless the transaction is going through my business, in which case it would be a markup. Or if there is an established commission initiated by the cabinet company, in which case it should be disclosed in your client agreement that you may make a commission on millwork. But to shake down the trades for an undisclosed commission for your referral is unethical at best, illegal at worst. (Any PA hours that come out of it would be billed hourly. )”
@katerinabuscemi
The distinction between a disclosed arrangement and a quiet one is not cosmetic. In several states, undisclosed compensation from a party you recommend touches real statutory exposure, and professional codes from the trade associations treat it as a conduct issue.
The practical fix is small. One clause stating that the firm may receive a commission or markup on millwork and allied trades, presented at signing rather than discovered at closeout. That belongs in the same family of language as deciding how transparent to be about product markup.
Educational content, not legal advice. Have your own attorney review the wording for your state, because the rules on vendor compensation vary and the cost of getting it wrong is a client relationship.
What the cabinet shop is paying for when it pays you
The supply side has its own view of this, and it is less fraught than the designer debate suggests. To a shop, a commission is customer acquisition, priced against the cost of finding that client another way.
“I pay commission for designers all the time, even they are not involved in the process. That is my way to say thank you for bringing me customers and trust me.”
@spiralids
Read that carefully, because it is the strongest argument for disclosure anywhere in this conversation. The payer is thanking you for the introduction. The client, if nobody tells them, assumes the specification was neutral. Both parties can be acting in good faith while holding incompatible understandings of the same payment.
It also explains why shop-initiated commission rates are rarely negotiable. They are a marketing line item, not a share of the project’s profit, which is why firms wanting real margin on millwork usually run the purchase through their own books instead.
Worth noting too: a commission paid for an introduction tends to assume nothing further is owed. If you accept one and then spend six weeks managing revisions and punch items, you have taken referral money for project management work. Decide which arrangement you are actually in before the rate gets set.
Understanding where a shop’s price comes from makes that negotiation shorter. Jonathan Rowland on how cabinetry gets quoted, built, and installed is thirty years of manufacturer’s rep perspective on exactly that question, including who absorbs a mistake once the boxes are on site.
Pick the model your responsibility can defend
There is no industry-wide answer here, and the firms arguing opposite positions are often both right for their own operations. What they share is alignment between what they are accountable for and what they are paid for.
So run the test in that order. Decide how much of this scope you own, from the drawing through the punch list. Then choose the model that funds that exposure: a markup if the purchase runs through you, a commission if the shop initiates one and you are still in the problem-solving chain, a fee if you are designing and handing off.
Then write it down before the project starts, in the agreement rather than in an email six weeks later. A client who knows the structure at signing almost never objects to it at closeout.
The firms that get burned on cabinetry compensation are almost never the ones who charged too much. They are the ones who never said out loud how they get paid.
Find IDC content more easily in Google
Set Interior Design Community as a preferred source in your Google settings and we’ll show up more often when you search. It takes less than a minute.
Add IDC as a preferred source →
